1005 points = 3 rolls + 1% chance of an extra roll.

750 points = 2 rolls + 50% chance of an extra roll.

505 points = 2 rolls + 1% chance of an extra roll.

For every 5 points past 500 points player gets 1% extra chance to get additional loot.

Points earned between the 500-point milestones will provide players a chance to receive an additional reward equivalent to the progress towards the next milestone. Tomes of fire may also be exchanged for 250 burnt pages. Players can exchange excess Wintertodt-unique items (excluding phoenix and burnt pages) with Ignisia for an extra supply crate (which contains one roll on the drop table and no chance of getting a unique item) or 50 burnt pages. Beyond this point, earning extra points does not increase the number of drops from a supply crate. With 13,500 points or above, players will receive 28 rewards, the maximum from any single supply crate. For every 500 points earned after the initial 500, another reward is added to the crate. Opening it will give players two rolls on the reward table. The supply crate also gives the opportunity for items only obtainable through defeating the Wintertodt, such as the tome of fire, pyromancer outfit, and the sought after phoenix pet. It can reward many useful items for skilling such as ores, logs, herbs, seeds, gems, and fish. A supply crate is obtained after earning at least 500 points during the fight against the Wintertodt.

Mass effect phoenix armor